By: Russell S. Richardson, Craig A. Harms, Bruno, Grassi, and Russell T. Hepple
Department of Medicine, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA; Department of Kinesiology, Kansas State University, Manhatten, KS; and Istituto di Tecnologie Biomediche Avanzate, National Research Council, Milano, ITALY.
RUSSELL S. RICHARDSON, CRAIG A. HARMS, BRUNO, GRASSI, and RUSSELL T. HEPPLE. Skeletal muscle: master or slave of the cardiovascular system? Med. Sci. Sports Exerc., Vol. 32, No. 1, pp. 89–93, 1999.
Skeletal muscle and cardiovascular system responses to exercise are so closely entwined that it is often difficult to determine the effector from the affector. The purpose of this manuscript and its companion papers is to highlight (and perhaps assist in unraveling) the interdependency between skeletal muscle and the cardiovascular system in both chronic and acute exercise. Specifically, we elucidate four main areas: 1) how a finite cardiac output is allocated to a large and demanding mass of skeletal muscle, 2) whether maximal muscle oxygen uptake is determined peripherally or centrally, 3) whether blood flow or muscle metabolism set the kinetic response to the start of exercise, and 4) the matching of structural adaptations in muscle and the microcirculation in response to exercise. This manuscript, the product of an American College of Sports Medicine Symposium, unites the thoughts and findings of four researchers, each with different interests and perspectives, but with the common intent to better understand the interaction between oxygen supply and metabolic demand during exercise.
Key Words: GAS EXCHANGE KINETICS, BLOOD FLOW DISTRIBUTION, LACTIC ACID, INTRACELLULAR PO2, CARDIAC OUTPUT, MUSCLE PLASTICITY, V˙O2MAX
Although recognizing the numerous physiological systems and the many interactions during exercise, still perhaps the most significant interplay is between the cardiorespiratory system and skeletal muscle, which determines both O2 supply and demand (Fig. 1). At the beginning of exercise, the integrated response of the pulmonary, cardiovascular, and muscular systems characterize the V˙O2 on-kinetics. This kinetic response is highly sensitive to aerobic training (31) and can be measured both at the mouth and across a muscle (10). However, the role that each system plays in determining the V˙O2 on-kinetics continues to be the subject of considerable debate (4,18).
Beyond this transitional period, we encounter the issue of blood flow distribution, which is the appropriate distribution of a finite cardiac output among essential organs such as the brain, heart, intestines (48), and the metabolically very active skeletal muscle involved in the exercise (32). Which area of demand takes precedence as the metabolic requirements increase and the limits of cardiac output are approached (11)? The introduction of isolated skeletal muscle models (2,51) has highlighted this issue of skeletal muscle perfusion under conditions of maximal cardiac output versus a small muscle mass where central components are less taxed, allowing a greater level of skeletal muscle perfusion to be achieved (41,47). Additionally, these skeletal muscle models have proved fruitful in another long standing area of study: the determinants of maximal metabolic rate (V˙O2max), specifically whether V˙O2max is governed by O2 supply or O2 demand (35,43). Finally, the study of the structural interface between the cardiovascular system and skeletal muscle can be a powerful approach to elucidating the interplay between these two systems. It can be experimentally demonstrated that O2 conductance from blood to muscle cell plays an important role in determining V˙ O2max (37,52), suggestive of a passive role played by the muscle itself. However, when exposed to a repeated exercise stimulus, skeletal muscle now takes a very active role and demonstrates a remarkable plasticity (17) that positively affects exercise capacity (16).
Thus, here again the issue of who is the master and who the slave in the relationship between the cardiovascular system and skeletal muscle is open to debate.
Muscular Perfusion: Determined by Muscular Demand or Cardiovascular Supply?
The greatest demand for cardiac output during exercise is from skeletal muscle, as nearly 85% of total blood flow is directed to the working legs during maximal cycle ergometry (20,32). Several investigations have examined how different groups of skeletal muscle compete for the cardiac output during exercise and whether a “steal” phenomenon exists. Although Secher et al. (50) observed a decrease in leg blood flow when arm exercise was added to two legged cycle ergometry, more recent investigations have failed to corroborate these findings (36,44,49). However, the majority of data suggest that some degree of leg vasoconstriction or an attempt to vasoconstrict, as determined from norepinephrine spillover, occurs when arm exercise is added to leg exercise (44,49). Recently, a set of experiments have been conducted to determine whether a different group of skeletal muscles, those associated with breathing, influence cardiac output and its distribution during maximal exercise (11–13,56). These reports have demonstrated that respiratory muscles demand a significant portion of the cardiac output, primarily through stroke volume and total V˙O2, approximating 14–16% of the total (12). Additionally, it was shown that during heavy exercise, this metabolic demand from the respiratory muscles affects the distribution of cardiac output between the respiratory muscles and the legs such that leg vascular conductance and blood flow increases with respiratory muscle unloading and decreases with respiratory loading (11). Exercise performance may also be affected by the work of breathing during heavy exercise due to redistribution of blood flow between the chest wall and the locomotor muscles (56). Therefore, it appears that, in contrast to arm versus leg exercise, respiratory muscle work normally encountered during maximal exercise significantly influences cardiac output and its distribution.
V˙O2max: Governed by Oxygen Supply or Demand?
It has now been repeatedly demonstrated that an increase in O2 delivery can increase V˙O2max (1,3,5,21,30,34,38,43,55), which suggests that O2 supply limitation exists. As the isolated human quadriceps exercise does not approach the upper limits of cardiac output, this exercise paradigm has previously unveiled a skeletal muscle metabolic reserve and results in the highest mass specific V˙O2 and work rates recorded in man (37,41,46). This observation in of itself is evidence of O2 supply limitation of muscle V˙O2max. In a recent human knee-extensor study, the V˙O2max increased with an elevated O2 delivery (hyperoxia) demonstrating that in normoxic conditions even in the highly perfused isolated quadriceps, muscle V˙O2max is not limited by mitochondrial metabolic rate, but rather by O2 supply (35).
Although it is clear that in many scenarios an increase in O2 delivery can increase V˙O2max, it has also been demonstrated that this is not the sole determinant; in fact, the interaction between the convective and diffusive components of O2 transport may ultimately set the maximal metabolic rate (52). In the isolated canine gastrocnemius preparation, infusion of the allosteric modifier of hemoglobin RSR13 (Allos Therapeutics, Denver, CO) significantly increased P50, and at a constant arterial O2 delivery resulted in an increase in O2 extraction and a consequent increase in muscle V˙O2max (43). This indicates, for the first time, that the canine gastrocnemius muscle is normally O2 supply-limited, even when the animal is breathing 100% O2. In addition, the increase inV˙ O2max was proportional to the increase in venous PO2. Taken together, these findings support the concept that the diffusion of O2 between the red cell and the mitochondria plays a role in determining V˙O2max.
The insinuation that the production of lactate with progressively intense muscular work is evidence of inadequate intramuscular oxygenation has been long lived (15). Since then, the term “anaerobic threshold” has been used to describe the point at which lactate begins to accumulate in the blood, thought to indicate the inadequacy of O2 supply for the metabolic demand (54). Magnetic resonance spectroscopy, utilizing myoglobin as an endogenous probe of intracellular PO2 (29,53), in combination with the isolated human quadriceps model (38) has revealed that in hypoxic or normoxic exercise conditions net muscle lactate efflux is independent of intracellular PO2. The former increases whereas the latter remains constant during progressive incremental exercise (39). However, in hypoxia intracellular PO2 is systematically decreased in comparison to normoxia, whereas the changes in intracellular pH and muscle lactate efflux are accelerated. Whereas the latter observations indicate that a role for intracellular PO2 as a modulator of metabolism cannot be ruled out, arterial epinephrine levels are closely related to skeletal muscle lactate efflux in both normoxia and hypoxia and thus may be a major stimulus for the observed rise in muscle lactate efflux during progressively intense exercise and for the elevated lactate efflux in hypoxia. We would postulate that it is systemic and not intracellular PO2 that increases catecholamine responses in hypoxia and is therefore responsible for the correspondingly higher net lactate efflux (39).
Recently, evidence supporting the importance of intracellular PO2 in determining skeletal muscle V˙O2max has come to light (38). Studies of intracellular PO2 in trained human skeletal muscle with varied FIO2 suggest that in hyperoxia there is the expected rise in intracellular PO2 (due to increased mean capillary PO2), but this elevated O2 availability is now in excess of mitochondrial capacity (40). Indicating that intracellular PO2 is a determinant of V˙O2max in each FIO2 (12, 21, and 100% O2) but that in the latter case the increased intracellular PO2 results in diminishing returns with respect to an increase in V˙O2max. These observations are consistent with cellular metabolism that is moving toward a transition between O2 supply and O2 demand as a determinant of V˙O2max. It seems that further increases in intracellular PO2, beyond those recorded in hyperoxia, may have smaller effects upon V˙O2max until a plateau is reached and V˙O2max becomes invariant with intracellular PO2. From this point, intracellular PO2 may no longer be a determinant of skeletal muscle V˙O2max. This hyperbolic relationship, perhaps stemming from the origin, between intracellular O2 tension and cellular respiration is similar to data previously presented by Wilson et al. (57) in which the metabolic rate of isolated kidney cells was demonstrated to be O2 supply dependent below a certain O2 availability. Again, these myoglobin-associated PO2 data fit with the supply dependence of V˙O2max in healthy exercise trained human skeletal muscle (35,37).
V˙O2 On-Kinetics: Set by Blood Flow or Muscle Metabolism?
Upon a step transition from rest to exercise, or from a lower to higher workload, O2 uptake (V˙O2) lags behind the power output increase, following a time course usually termed V˙O2 on-kinetics. The mechanism(s) determining this kinetic response has been a matter of considerable debate between those who consider it mainly related to the rate of adjustment of O2 delivery to the exercising muscles and those supporting the concept that the V˙O2 on-kinetics is mainly set by an inertia of intramuscular oxidative metabolism.
In recent years, experiments in both exercising humans (9,10) and in the isolated in situ dog gastrocnemius preparation (7,8) have provided evidence in favor of the “metabolic inertia” hypothesis. Specifically, the transition from unloaded-to-loaded pedalling (below the “ventilatory threshold”) was studied in humans.
Blood flow to one of the exercising limbs was determined continuously by a modified constant-infusion thermodilution technique, andV˙O2 across the limb was determined every ;5s by the Fick principle. Leg blood flow rose rapidly upon the change in work intensity, whereas arteriovenous O2 concentration difference across the limb did not increase during the first 10–15 s of the transition (10). During this type of metabolic transition, therefore, muscle O2 utilization kinetics lag behind the kinetics of bulk O2 delivery to muscle.
Heart transplant recipients show a slower V˙O2 on-kinetics compared with healthy controls. This slower V˙O2 onkinetics may be attributed to a slower adjustment of heart rate, cardiac output, and O2 delivery to muscles. In a group of heart transplant recipients, a “warm-up” exercise, performed before a rest-to-50-W transition, resulted in a slightly faster adjustment of cardiac output and more favourable conditions as far as O2 delivery to exercising muscles but did not speed up the V˙ O2 on-kinetics (9). Again, indicative of the lag in O2 uptake originating in the muscle itself.
By utilizing the isolated in situ dog gastrocnemius preparation, the metabolic transition from rest-to-electrically stimulated tetanic contractions corresponding to ;70% of V˙O2max was studied (7). The delay in the adjustment of convective O2 delivery to muscle was completely eliminated by pump-perfusing the muscle, at rest and during contractions, at a constant level of blood flow corresponding to the steady state value obtained during contractions in preliminary trials conducted with spontaneous adjustment of muscle blood flow (muscle perfused via the contralateral femoral artery). Adenosine was infused intra-arterially to prevent any vasoconstriction associated with the elevated muscle blood flow. Elimination of delay in convective O2 delivery did not affect muscle V˙O2 on-kinetics, which was not different to that observed in control conditions (7).
Finally, another study was conducted on the isolated in situ dog gastrocnemius preparation, during the same metabolic transition described above. Peripheral O2 diffusion was enhanced by having the dogs breathe a hyperoxic gas mixture and by the administration of RSR 13 (Allos Therapeutics), which right-shifts the oxy-hemoglobin dissociation curve. Mean capillary PO2 (PcapO2) was estimated by numerical integration. Hyperoxic breathing and RSR 13 significantly increased PcapO2 (i.e., the driving force for peripheral O2 diffusion) at rest and during contractions but did not affect muscle V˙O2 on-kinetics (8). Taken together, the results of this study and the previous one indicate that, in this experimental model, neither convective nor diffusive O2 delivery to muscle fibers affects muscleV˙ O2 on-kinetics, supporting the hypothesis that the latter is mainly set by an inertia of muscle oxidative metabolism. These conclusions appear in agreement with observations obtained by other authors in humans during step transitions to workloads lower than the “ventilatory threshold” (6,24). It should be noted, however, that these authors indicate that during step transitions to workloads higher than the “ventilatory threshold” the kinetics of O2 delivery to muscle appears to be a critical factor in determining the V˙O2 on-kinetics.
Plasticity of Skeletal Muscle: Microcirculatory Adaptation to Metabolic Demand?
The issue of whether skeletal muscle is master or slave of the cardiovascular system depends on frame of reference. Although acute manipulations of convective O2 delivery clearly show that O2 supply sets the upper limit of mitochondrial respiratory rate (42), interspecies comparisons (23) and study of adaptation to chronic conditions such as physical training show that capillarization (14,19) and mitochondrial development (28,45) are key components of the adaptive response in systemic V˙O2max. In addition, adaptations in the structural capacity for aerobic metabolism in skeletal muscle are closely regulated (e.g., close matching of capillary supply and fiber mitochondrial content) (26,33) and are maintained in proportion to the aerobic capacity of the whole organism (17). The study of adaptive variation in skeletal muscle structure within and between species has revealed design features that are uniform throughout muscles of widely varying metabolic demand. One of these features is that the size of the capillaryto- fiber interface rather than diffusion distance relates most closely to the structural capacity for O2 flux into muscle fibers (27). Recent studies have also shown that the size of the capillary-to-fiber interface is matched to mitochondrial volume/ fiber length with adaptation to training (33), electrical stimulation (26), and chronic hypoxia (25). These observations suggest another regulated design feature in skeletal muscle is matching the structural capacity for O2 flux to fiber metabolic demand (33).
Changes in capillarization and fiber mitochondrial content are important parts of the adaptive response to exercise training. In older humans, both high-intensity resistance training and aerobic training increase the size of the capillary-to-fiber interface (14). Furthermore, the change in V˙O2max is related to changes in the size of the capillary-to-fiber interface rather than capillary density, suggesting an increase in the structural capacity for O2 flux is an important feature of the adaptation in V˙O2max with both modes of training in this population (14).
Similarly, mitochondrial electron transport chain (ETC) capacity appears important to muscle V˙O2max. Poisoning of complex III (NADH-cytochrome c reductase) of the ETC results in a stepwise reduction in peak muscle O2 (27) and reduces peak muscle V˙O2 to pretraining levels in trained rat hindlimb muscle (45). It is noteworthy that this occurs even when muscle metabolism, blood flow, and convective O2 delivery are markedly lower than seen during maximal exercise in vivo (22).
In conclusion, there appears to be a paradox between the well-known increase in V˙O2max that occurs with increased O2 delivery and the proportional alterations in V˙O2max that accompany manipulations in mitochondrial oxidative capacity at submaximal O2 delivery and submaximal metabolic demand.
This, in conjunction with the observation that adaptation in skeletal muscle structural capacity for O2 flux (e.g., increased capillarization and fiber mitochondrial content) occurs in response to alterations in metabolic demand through exercise training and chronic hypoxia, supports an independent role of skeletal muscle in determining systemic V˙O2max.
It is clear that both on a functional and structural level the response of the cardiovascular system and skeletal muscle are closely linked. Here we have addressed the issue of which of these systems is dominant and which more submissive.
Although we offer insight to this question, perhaps the most striking observation is that a single answer would not be appropriate as the role of each system appears to be highly dependent upon a multitude of factors that together create the scenario under investigation. A change in one of these variables, for example, acute exercise becoming chronic exercise, will markedly alter the relationship between the cardiovascular system and skeletal muscle and change the answer to the question of control.
Funding was provided by NIH 17731, RR02305, and HL-15469, and Dr. Richardson and Dr. Harms were supported by Parker B. Francis Fellowships in Pulmonary Research.
Address for correspondence: Russell S. Richardson, Ph.D., Department of Medicine, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 90293-0623. E-mail: email@example.com.
1. ADAMS, R. P., and H. G.WELCH. Oxygen uptake, acid base status, and performance with varied inspired oxygen fractions. J. Appl. Physiol. 49:863–868, 1980.
2. ANDERSEN, P., and B. SALTIN. Maximal perfusion of skeletal muscle in man. J. Physiol. 366:233–249, 1985.
3. BARCLAY, J. K., and W. N. STAINSBY. The role of blood flow in limiting maximal metabolic rate in muscle. Med. Sci. Sports. 7:116–119, 1975.
4. CERRETELLI, P., D. W. RENNIE, and D. R. PENDERGAST. Kinetics of metabolic transients during exercise. In: Exercise Bioenergetics and Gas Exchange, P. Cerretelli, and B. J. Whipp (Eds.). Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1980, pp. 187–209.
5. DUHAYLONGSOD, F. G., J. A. GRIEBEL, D. S. BACON, W. G. WOLFE, and C. A. PIANTADOSI. Effects of muscle contraction on cytochrome a, a3 redox state. J. Appl. Physiol. 75:790 –797, 1993.
6. GERBINO, A., S. A.WARD, and B. J.WHIPP. Effects of prior exercise on pulmonary gas exchange kinetics during high-intensity exercise in humans. J. Appl. Physiol. 80:99 –107, 1996.
7. GRASSI, B., L. B. GLADDEN, M. SAMAJA, C. M. STARY, and M. C. HOGAN. Faster adjustment of O2 delivery does not affect VO2 onkinetics in isolated in situ canine muscle. J. Appl. Physiol. 85, 1998.
8. GRASSI, B., L. B. GLADDEN, C. M. STARY, P. D. WAGNER, and M. C. HOGAN. Peripheral O2 diffusion does not affect VO2 on-kinetics in isolated in situ canine muscle. J. Appl. Physiol. 85, 1998.
9. GRASSI, B., C. MARCONI, M. MEYER, M. RIEU, and P. CERRETELLI. Gas exchange and cardiovascular kinetics upon different exercise protocols in heart transplant recipients. J. Appl. Physiol. 82:1952–1962, 1997.
10. GRASSI, B., D. C. POOLE, R. S. RICHARDSON, D. R. KNIGHT, B. K. ERICKSON, and P. D. WAGNER. Muscle O2 uptake kinetics in humans: implications for metabolic control. J. Appl. Physiol. 80:988–998, 1996.
11. HARMS, C. A., M. A. BABCOCK, S. R. MCCLARAN, et al. Respiratory muscle work compromises leg blood flow during maximal exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 82:1573–1583, 1997.
12. HARMS, C. A., T. WETTER, S. R. MCCLAREN, et al. Effect of respiratory muscle work on cardiac output and its distribution
during maximal exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 85:609–618, 1998.
13. HARMS, C. A., T. WETTER, C. ST. CROIX, D. F. PEGELOW, and J. A. DEMPSEY. Increased power output at VO2max with respiratory muscle unloading. Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 30:S41, 1998.
92 Official Journal of the American College of Sports Medicine http://www.msse.org
14. HEPPLE, R. T., S. L. M.MACKINNON, J. M. GOODMAN, S. G. THOMAS, and M. J. PLYLEY. Resistance and aerobic training in older men: effects on VO2 peak and the capillary supply to skeletal muscle. J. Appl. Physiol. 82:1305–1310, 1997.
15. HILL, A. V., C. N. H. LONG, and H. LUPTON. Muscular exercise, lactic acid, and the supply and utilization of oxygen. Part IV: the
oxygen debt at the end of exercise. Proc. R. Soc. (Lond.) Series B 97:127–137, 1924.
16. HOPPELER, H., H. HOWALD, K. CONLEY, et al. Endurance training in humans: aerobic capacity and structure of skeletal muscle. J. Appl. Physiol. 59:320 –327, 1985.
17. HOPPELER, H., and S. L. LINDSTEDT. Malleability of skeletal muscle in overcoming limitations: structural elements. J. Exp. Biol. 115: 355–364, 1985.
18. HUGHSON, R. L., J. K. SHOEMAKER, M. E. TSCHAKOVSKY, and J. M. KOWALCHUCK. Dependence of muscle VO2 on blood flow dynamics at the onset of forearm exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 81:1619– 1626, 1996.
19. INGJER, F. Maximal aerobic power related to capillary supply in the quadriceps femoris muscle in man. Acta Physiol. Scand. 104:238–240, 1978.
20. KNIGHT, D. R., D. C. POOLE, W. SCHAFFARTZIK, et al. Relationship between body and leg VO2 during maximal cycle ergometry. J. Appl. Physiol. 73:1114 –1121, 1992.
21. KNIGHT, D. R., W. SCHAFFARTZIK, D. C. POOLE, M. C. HOGAN, D. E. BEBOUT, and P. D. WAGNER. Hyperoxia increases leg maximal oxygen uptake. J. Appl. Physiol. 75:2586 –2594, 1993.
22. LAUGHLIN, M. H., and R. B. ARMSTRONG. Muscular blood flow distribution patterns as a function of running speed in rats. Am. J. Physiol. 243:H296–H306, 1982.
23. LINDSTEDT, S. L., D. J. WELLS, J. H. JONES, H. HOPPELER, and H. A. THRONSON, JR. Limitations to aerobic performance in mammals: interaction of structure and and demand. Int. J. Sports Med. 9:210 –217, 1988.
24. MACDONALD, M., P. K. PEDERSEN, and R. L. HUGHSON. Acceleration of VO2 kinetics in heavy submaximal exercise in hyperoxia and prior high-intensity exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 83:1318–1325, 1997.
25. MATHIEU-COSTELLO, O., P. J. AGEY, L. WU, J. M. SZEWCZAK, and R. E. MCMILLEN. Increased fiber capillarization in flight muscle of finch at altitude. Respir. Physiol. 111:189 –199, 1998.
26. MATHIEU-COSTELLO, O., P. J. AGEY, L. WU, J. HANG, and T. H. 0ADAIR. Capillary-to-fiber surface ratio in rat fast-twitch hindlimb muscles after chronic electrical stimulation. J. Appl. Physiol. 80: 904–909, 1996.
27. MATHIEU-COSTELLO, O., R. K. SAUREZ, and P. W. HOWCHACHKA. Capillary-to-fiber geometry and mitochondrial density in hummingbird flight muscle. Respir. Physiol. 89:113–132, 1992.
28. MCALLISTER, R. M., and R. L. TERJUNG. Acute inhibition of respiratory capacity of muscle reduces peak oxygen consumption. Am. J. Physiol. 259:C889–C896, 1990.
29. NOYSZEWSKI, E. A., E. L. CHEN, R. REDDY, Z. WANG, and J. S. LEIGH. A simplified sequence for observing deoxymyoglobin signals in vivo: myoglobin excitation with dynamic unexcitation and saturation of water and fat. Magn. Reson. Med. 38:788 –792, 1997.
30. PELTONEN, J. E., J. RANTAMAKI, S. P. NIITTYMAKI, K. SWEINS, J. T. VIITASALO, and H. K. RUSKO. Effects of oxygen fraction in inspired air on rowing performance. Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 27:573–579, 1995.
31. PHILLIPS, S. M., H. J. GREEN, M. J. MACDONALD, and R. L. HUGHSON. Progressive effect of endurance training on VO2 kinetics at the onset of submaximal exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 79:1914–1920, 1995.
32. POOLE, D. C., G. A. GAESSER, M. C. HOGAN, D. R. KNIGHT, and P. D. WAGNER. Pulmonary and leg VO2 during submaximal exercise: implications for muscular efficiency. J. Appl. Physiol. 72: 805–810, 1992.
33. POOLE, D. C., and O. MATHIEU-COSTELLO. Relationship between fiber capillarization and mitochondrial volume density in control and trained rat soleus and plantaris muscles. Microcirculation 3:175–186, 1996.
34. POWERS, S. K., J. LAWLER, J. A. DEMPSEY, S. DODD, and G. LANDRY. Effects of incomplete pulmonary gas exchange on VO2max. J. Appl. Physiol. 66:2491–2495, 1989.
35. RICHARDSON, R. S., B. GRASSI, T. P. GAVIN, L. J. HASELER, K. TAGORE, J. ROCA, and P. D. WAGNER. Evidence of supply-dependent VO2max in the exercise-trained human quadriceps. J. Appl. Physiol. 86:1048 –1053, 1999.
36. RICHARDSON, R. S., B. KENNEDY, D. R. KNIGHT, and P. D. WAGNER. High muscle blood flows are not attenuated by recruitment of additional muscle mass. Am. J. Physiol. 269:H1545–H1552, 1995.
37. RICHARDSON, R. S., D. R. KNIGHT, D. C. POOLE, et al. Determinants of maximal exercise VO2 during single leg knee extensor exercise in humans. Am. J. Physiol. 268:H1453–H1461, 1995.
38. RICHARDSON, R. S., E. A. NOYSZESKI, K. F. KENDRICK, J. S. LEIGH, and P. D. WAGNER. Myoglobin O2 desaturation during exercise: evidence of limited O2 transport. J. Clin. Invest. 96:1916–1926, 1995.
39. RICHARDSON, R. S., E. A. NOYSZEWSKI, J. S. LEIGH, and P. D. WAGNER. Lactate efflux from exercising human skeletal muscle: role of intracellular PO2. J. Appl. Physiol. 85:627– 634, 1998.
40. RICHARDSON, R. S., E. A. NOYSZEWSKI, J. S. LEIGH, and P. D. WAGNER. Cellular PO2 as a determinant of maximal mitochondrial O2 consumption in trained human skeletal muscle. J. Appl. Physiol. 87:325–331; 1999.
41. RICHARDSON, R. S., D. C. POOLE, D. R. KNIGHT, et al. High muscle blood flow in man: is maximal O2 extraction compromised? J. Appl. Physiol. 75:1911–1916, 1993.
42. RICHARDSON, R. S., and B. SALTIN. Human muscle blood flow and metabolism studied in the isolated quadriceps muscles. Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 30:28 –33, 1998.
43. RICHARDSON, R. S., K. TAGORE, L. HASELER, M. JORDAN, and P. D. WAGNER. Increased VO2max with right shifted HbO2 dissociation curve at a constant O2 delivery in dog muscle in situ. J. Appl. Physiol. 84:995–1002, 1998.
44. RICHTER, E. A., B. KIENS, M. HARGREAVES, and M. KAEJER. Effect of arm cranking on leg blood flow and noradrenaline spillover during leg exercise in man. Acta Physiol. Scand. 144:9 –14, 1992.
45. ROBINSON, D. M., R. W. OGILIVIE, P. C. TULLSON, and R. L. TERJUNG. Increased peak oxygen consumption of trained muscle requires increased electron flux capacity. J. Appl. Physiol. 77: 1941–1952, 1994.
46. ROWELL, L. B. Muscle blood flow how high can it go? Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 20:S97–S103, 1988.
47. ROWELL, L. B., B. SALTIN, B. KIENS, and N. J. CHRISTENSEN. Is peak quadriceps blood flow in humans even higher during exercise with hypoxemia? Am. J. Physiol. 251:H1038–H1044, 1986.
48. SALTIN, B. Hemodynamic adaptions to exercise. Am. J. Cardiol. 55:42D–47D, 1985.
49. SAVARD, G. K., E. A. RICHTER, S. STRANGE, B. KIENS, N. J. CHRISTENSEN, and B. SALTIN. Norepinephrine spillover from skeletal muscle during exercise: role of muscle mass. Am. J. Physiol. 257:H1812–H1818, 1989.
50. SECHER, N. H., J. P. CLAUSEN, K. KLAUSEN, I. NOER, and J. TRAPJENSEN. Central and regional circulatory effects of adding arm exercise to leg exercise. Acta Physiol. Scand. 100:288 –297, 1977.
51. STAINSBY, W. N., and A. B. OTIS. Blood flow, blood oxygen tension, oxygen uptake, and oxygen transport in skeletal muscle. Am. J. Physiol. 206:858–866, 1964.
52. WAGNER, P. D. Gas exchange and peripheral diffusion limitation. Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 24:54 –58, 1992.
53. WANG, Z., E. A. NOYSZEWSKI, and J. S. LEIGH. In vivo MRS measurement of deoxymyoglobin in human forearms. Magn. Reson. Med. 14:562–567, 1990.
54. WASSERMAN, K., and M. B. MCILROY. Detecting the threshold of anaerobic metabolism in cardiac patients during exercise. Am. J. Cardiol. 14:844–859, 1964.
55. WELCH, H. G. Hyperoxia and human performance: a brief review. Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 14:253–262, 1982.
56. WETTER, T. J., C. A. HARMS, C. ST. CROIX, D. F. PEGLOW, and J. A. DEMPSEY. Effects of respiratory muscle loading and unloading on time to exhaustion during cycle ergometry. Med. Sci. Sports. Exerc. 30:S190, 1998.
57. WILSON, D. F., M. ERECINSKA, C. DROWN, and I. A. SILVER. Effect of oxygen tension on cellular energetics. Am. J. Physiol. 233: C135–C140, 1977.